A cat is found to have died from gross negligence and the board rounds it down

Complaint: Complaint 18-63
Respondent: Robert Thrift
Premises: Bell Animal and Bird Hospital

The complainant says she found her cat seriously injured in her back yard and rushed her cat to Thrift's clinic. He was eventually examined, and the complainant says that Thrift told her that the cat looked bad but would be okay, recommending morphine and eyedrops. She says she asked if she could go to a 24-hour clinic, but that Thrift said those places just take your money. The complainant says her cat did worse overnight and started gurgling so she took the cat back the next morning, where the manager supposedly said that the cat should be somewhere else and that Thrift often gets tired or forgets things. She took her cat to 1st Pet where the staff told her that the cat had multiple injuries and should be euthanized.

Thrift's response provides some medical details and contests much of what the complainant said. He states that he suggested going to an emergency clinic as an option and that BluePearl's address was provided. He also says that he said that emergency clinics were not cheap, not that they would drain her of money.

The Investigative Committee seems to have overall believed the complainants in this case. The Committee found that Thrift should have referred the cat to an emergency facility instead of waiting, also finding that Thrift discouraged the complainant from taking the cat to an emergency facility. They found three violations including gross negligence and failure to refer to an emergency facility, but the veterinary board only kept one of the violations related to record-keeping.

Motions

Investigative Motion: Find violation

Source: May 5, 2018 AM Investigative Committee Meeting
People:
David Stoll Respondent Attorney
Robert Thrift Respondent
Roll Call:
Christina Tran Aye
Mary Williams Aye
Robert Kritsberg Aye
Ryan Ainsworth Aye
Violations:
ARS 32-2232 (12) as it relates to AAC R3-11-501 (3) failure to refer the cat to an emergency facility and document it in the medical record;
ARS 32-2232 (11) Gross negligence; for failure to diagnose the rib fractures and mandibular symphyseal fracture on radiographs or physical exam on January 22, 2018
ARS 32-2232 (21) as it relates to AAC R3-11-502 (L) (8) failure to document the amount, concentration and frequency of buprenorphine prescribed on January 22, 2018.
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Schedule informal interview

Source: June 6, 2018 Board Meeting
People:
David Stoll Respondent Attorney
Proposed By: Darren Wright
Seconded By: Jessica Creager
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Absent
Darren Wright Aye
J Greg Byrne Absent
Jessica Creager Aye
Jim Loughead Aye
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Aye
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Aye
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Find violation

Source: August 8, 2018 Board Meeting
People:
David Stoll Respondent Attorney
Robert Thrift Respondent
Proposed By: Darren Wright
Seconded By: Robyn Jaynes
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Aye
Darren Wright Aye
J Greg Byrne Absent
Jessica Creager Recused
Jim Loughead Aye
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Aye
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Aye
Violations:
ARS 32-2232 (21) Failure to document in the medical record
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Issue letter of concern

Source: August 8, 2018 Board Meeting
People:
David Stoll Respondent Attorney
Robert Thrift Respondent
Proposed By: Darren Wright
Seconded By: Christina Bertch-Mumaw
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Aye
Darren Wright Aye
J Greg Byrne Absent
Jessica Creager Recused
Jim Loughead Aye
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Aye
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Aye
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Issue board order

Source: September 9, 2018 Board Meeting
Proposed By: Darren Wright
Seconded By: Christina Bertch-Mumaw
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Aye
Darren Wright Aye
J Greg Byrne Aye
Jessica Creager Absent
Jim Loughead Aye
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Aye
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Aye
Result: Passed

Board Order: Order 18063 ROBERT THRIFT, DVM

Source: Order 18063 (October 10, 2018)
Violations:
A.R.S. ยง 32-2232 (21) as it relates to A.A.C. R3-11-502 (L) (8) failure to document the amount, concentration and frequency of buprenorphine prescribed on January 22, 2018.
Penalties:
Probation (1 year)
Continuing education (4 hours in medical record keeping)
Civil penalty ($500)

The primary source for the above summary was obtained as a public record from the Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board. You are welcome to review the original records and board meeting minutes by clicking the relevant links. While we endeavor to provide an accurate summary of the complaint, response, investigative reports and board actions, we encourage you to review the primary sources and come to your own conclusions. In some cases we have also been able to reach out to individuals with knowledge of specific complaints, and where possible that information will be included here.