A do-gooder veterinarian euthanizes an underdog because she says it mauled the crap out of her

Complaint: Complaint 18-98
Respondent: Carol Rowand
Premises: Corona Veterinary Service

Rowand applied to foster with Underdog Rescue of Arizona and was given two dogs from Pinal County Animal Control by a volunteer. The complainant, the rescue in this case, says she emailed the rescue stating that one of the dogs had been involved in a fight with another dog and asked for instructions. The rescue responded that many dogs from shelters have some aggression and that they only euthanize dogs deemed "Red Zone Aggressive" by their professional dog trainer. They say they directed Rowand to keep the dog away from other dogs until they could place the dog in a no-dog home. Rowand is said to have replied that she would do so but thought that euthanizing the dog would be best because he's unpredictable. Apparently, the rescue replied again stating that they would not euthanize the dog. A volunteer later learned that Rowand had gone ahead and euthanized the dog.

Rowand's response states that she has not replied to the veterinary board because her business has closed down and she is dealing with intense psychological trauma (her words) that led her to take a break from veterinary work. She says that the complainant grossly misrepresented the situation and that the dog had belonged to her for over a month. She also says that the dog nearly killed her dog and then mauled her too. She says that she has permanent nerve and tendon damage, a partially paralyzed hand, and that the damage is so great she can no longer work. She also notes that she never asked the rescue to compensate her for the medical bills and that the rescue would not accept the dog back when she asked. After no longer hearing from the rescue she says she considered the dog hers and euthanized it. She says she was scared every day and terrified of going outside because the dog was in her yard. She said it would be irresponsible to rehome it and that she has very serious concerns about Underdog Rescue.

The Investigative Committee said that the situation was "unfortunate" but perfectly legal. Rowand's license to practice in Arizona was later revoked in association with case 18-84.

Motions

Investigative Motion: Dismiss with no violation

Source: August 8, 2018 PM Investigative Committee Meeting
People:
Carol Rowand Respondent
Roll Call:
Adam Almaraz Aye
Amrit Rai Aye
Christine Butkiewicz Aye
Donald Noah Aye
William Hamilton Aye
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Schedule informal interview

Source: September 9, 2018 Board Meeting
Proposed By: Robyn Jaynes
Seconded By: Julie Young
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Aye
Darren Wright Nay
J Greg Byrne Aye
Jessica Creager Aye
Jim Loughead Nay
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Nay
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Nay
Result: Passed

Board Motion: Find violation

Source: October 10, 2018 Board Meeting
Proposed By: Robyn Jaynes
Seconded By: Jessica Creager
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Nay
Darren Wright Nay
J Greg Byrne Absent
Jessica Creager Aye
Jim Loughead Nay
Julie Young Absent
Nikki Frost Aye
Robyn Jaynes Aye
Sarah Heinrich Nay
Violations:
ARS 32-2232 (2) Failure to provide professionally acceptable procedures
Result: Failed

Board Motion: Dismiss with no violation

Source: October 10, 2018 Board Meeting
Proposed By: Sarah Heinrich
Seconded By: Darren Wright
Roll Call:
Christina Bertch-Mumaw Aye
Darren Wright Aye
J Greg Byrne Absent
Jessica Creager Nay
Jim Loughead Aye
Julie Young Aye
Nikki Frost Nay
Robyn Jaynes Nay
Sarah Heinrich Aye
Result: Passed

The primary source for the above summary was obtained as a public record from the Arizona State Veterinary Medical Examining Board. You are welcome to review the original records and board meeting minutes by clicking the relevant links. While we endeavor to provide an accurate summary of the complaint, response, investigative reports and board actions, we encourage you to review the primary sources and come to your own conclusions. In some cases we have also been able to reach out to individuals with knowledge of specific complaints, and where possible that information will be included here.